South Shore Geneva Lakefront Estate closes at $6.13 Million
Tucked behind a long, melodic driveway on Geneva Lake’s revered south shore, this legacy estate—sold by Hans Melges of Melges Real Estate—represents a rare convergence of privacy, prestige, and provenance. Once belonging to the Plunkett family, icons in America’s furniture manufacturing legacy, this lakefront home carries with it the soul of craftsmanship and the dignity of generational ownership. The Plunketts, known for their contributions to the evolution of home interiors, chose this extraordinary 1.65-acre parcel not just for its 80 feet of crystal-clear frontage, but for its unspoken power: the west end of the south shore, a corridor many regard as untouchable—where properties pass through families, not the open market. As Hugh Plunkett once emphasized in his industry reflections, “A home is not just where you live; it’s where your story is made.” That sentiment resonates throughout this 8,300-square-foot estate, where every room—from the vaulted-ceiling great room to the lake-facing walkout rec space—is a chapter written in timeless architecture.
Designed in 2000, the residence blends a lakefront leodic aesthetic with modern luxury, offering six bedrooms, 6.5 baths, and over 20 rooms thoughtfully scaled for both full-time residency and elegant entertaining. With distinct zones for living, lounging, and lake life, the home caters to multigenerational use and sleeps 20+ guests—an increasingly valuable trait for investors and families seeking flexible use or short-term income potential. The main-floor primary suite overlooks the lake, while four additional bedrooms upstairs and a separate guest wing ensure privacy across levels. Downstairs, a 42-foot rec room, game space, and family room stretch toward walkout glass doors, bringing the outside in and creating seamless access to the private dock, pier, and boat lift.
The location is unmatched—just west of the Lake Geneva Yacht Club, and walkable to Abbey Springs—placing the home within a coveted lifestyle pocket. Yet what truly sets this estate apart is what you don’t see from the road: its commanding pillared entry and secluded setting offer a rare, almost regal arrival experience. It’s this approach—private yet expected on Geneva’s south shore—that defines elite lakefront living. With zoning protections, high-speed internet, full municipal services, and a heated four-car garage, the property is as practical as it is palatial. Additional features like multiple fireplaces, a kitchen island with premium appliances, and a deck with a full sprinkler system ensure comfort in every season.
Represented and sold by Hans Melges, this $6,131,591.53 closed sale is a testament to the enduring value of Geneva Lake’s west end. The home was under contract within just 10 days—underscoring the market’s appetite for heritage properties with unrepeatable settings. For buyers and investors alike, this sale confirms what seasoned locals have long known: south shore real estate is more than a place—it’s a legacy. To explore other luxury properties or learn more about Geneva Lake’s most exclusive shoreline enclaves, visit Melges Real Estate and connect directly with Hans at (262) 745-3755.